85mm vs 70-200 2.8 for portraits? WHICH IS BETTER?

85mm vs 70-200 2.8 for portraits? WHICH IS BETTER?



In this video, I take my wife out for a photoshoot in downtown Chicago with the new 70-200mm gmaster and 85mm 1.4 lenses!
My favorite gear for photography:

My favorite gear for filmaking:

My favorite gear for flash photography:

*Gear used in video (Purchase here to support my channel) Thanks

Sony a7rii

Sony 85mm 1.4 Gmaster

Sony 70-200 Gmaster

Filmed on

Atomos Ninja 2

Sony a6500

10-18f4

Rode videomicro

FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA
Instagram
Join my Facebook Photo sharing group
Facebook Fan page
Snapchat mannythephotog
Follow Diana on Instagram
10% off squarespace website:

Comments

37 responses to “85mm vs 70-200 2.8 for portraits? WHICH IS BETTER?”

  1. @foreverjjun Avatar
    @foreverjjun

    Instead of 'which is better video, I hope for 'each is for this type of scenario' video.

  2. @Manna_Acharjee Avatar
    @Manna_Acharjee

    70 200 best…

  3. @danielj8177 Avatar
    @danielj8177

    I mean the 70-200 has 85 in it’s rage so..? I shoot at 2.8 with prime lenses and moving subjects anyway so the whole face is in focus. The Nikon z70-200 is just as sharp from a regular image viewing standpoint. If you pixel peep then obviously not but nobody cares how sharp an image is zoomed in 400%.

  4. @rodtapia Avatar
    @rodtapia

    Good perspective of analysis. Communication with model and relation with distance!

  5. @jgarcia237 Avatar
    @jgarcia237

    6:27 after few years then you get to afford it. XD

  6. @Began2011 Avatar
    @Began2011

    This was a very good comparison. The 85 1.4 is just a good lens and focal length.

  7. @poravich Avatar
    @poravich

    85 mm is perfectly suited for indoor portraits. 135mm is a perfect outdoor portrait lens. 70-200 mm is a versatile lens specifically designed for outdoor candid, not portraits, imo. I know some photographers who use 80-200 mm for indoor wedding photography, coupled with 85mm lens on their second camera.

  8. @Luko007 Avatar
    @Luko007

    Very good. Thank you.

  9. @thegeneral123 Avatar
    @thegeneral123

    I am a landscape, architecture and travel focused amateur photographer so for me I'd guess that a very fast 85mm prime would be best but I'd use my Tamron 70-180 F2.8 with my A7IV if I had to do portraits in a pinch. I just don't have any more suitable lenses on my X-T3 or A7IV as it's just not my focus. Maybe my Sigma 24-70 F2.8 or my Fuji 16-55 F2.8?

  10. @northparkfilms3045 Avatar
    @northparkfilms3045

    shoot weddings looking for a lens to separate people from the background during speeches and ceremony. I was contemplating the 70-20] f4, 85mm 1.8 and the 90mm macro 2.8. Is the compression at 200 significantly better than what I would get with those other lenses?

  11. @JKGartlandJr Avatar
    @JKGartlandJr

    Thank you !!!!

  12. @paigecfrancis Avatar
    @paigecfrancis

    You’ve come a long way since this video bro. I just watched this (again) because I’m planning a headshot session soon at night and wanted to figure out what’s best between my 85 1.8 and the Tammy 70-180. Still can’t make a decision so I guess I’ll try both. 🤷🏾‍♂️. These things happen.

  13. @michaelbell75 Avatar
    @michaelbell75

    5:14 haha. Funny to watch this now considering the 200mm is your new favorite lens. You know you don't have to shoot a 70-200 at 200 right? You can shoot it at 85mm, plus you also got 70-199…

  14. @juanurtaza6453 Avatar
    @juanurtaza6453

    Great Video Manny, What Kind of Focus You Used?

  15. @papsny Avatar
    @papsny

    Just saying hello from 2021

  16. @sygad1 Avatar
    @sygad1

    keep the video still for the love of god, feels like im on a roller coaster

  17. @thispak Avatar
    @thispak

    24mm-70mm f2.8 GM the best.

  18. @suryapratapsingh2348 Avatar
    @suryapratapsingh2348

    Who's watching this after he's a Pro now

  19. @djrease7354 Avatar
    @djrease7354

    Buy both 135mm and 70-200mm … lol they complement each other… lol

  20. @Bushcraft242 Avatar
    @Bushcraft242

    Awsome photography

  21. @daxshell242 Avatar
    @daxshell242

    Lol. As much as I love the corporate presentation intro, I love the style your have grown into today.

  22. @dbsouza1 Avatar
    @dbsouza1

    Isn't that like asking, which is better, a car or a truck?

  23. @copicgirl8057 Avatar
    @copicgirl8057

    I finally own both tomorrow (but on a Nikon) and it took me ages to save the money haha 😀

  24. @satishbamal8447 Avatar
    @satishbamal8447

    hopefully, you will be able to afford 200 mm F2 pretty soon, thanks for the video and I guess 70-200 is better in terms of what you can do with it (wildlife, bird photography, sports, and portraits, and some landscape), and 85 mm 1.4 is good if you are just wanting to focus on one thing and get the best results.

  25. @kbdigitalpvd Avatar
    @kbdigitalpvd

    Didn't know you're in Chicago, we're in Rockford and come shoot there quite often. Good stuff!

  26. @ummagumma9969 Avatar
    @ummagumma9969

    Is that situation to shoot wide open? Both background and model are equal subjects

  27. @GiveMeFaceCo Avatar
    @GiveMeFaceCo

    My Full Body Portraits on any lens other than a wide, come out looking trash 🤣🤣🤣 I’ve tried all types of stuff..
    I just did a shoot on my new RP, 50m 1.4f, EVERY shot the focus was off. 🙄

  28. @ajazahmed3694 Avatar
    @ajazahmed3694

    Fantastic images

  29. @-shagya2098 Avatar
    @-shagya2098

    Im from srilanka your tutorials are great

  30. @saintmovies7735 Avatar
    @saintmovies7735

    My 70-200 gm is definitely sharper wide open than my 85 gm wide open….albeit the 85 is at F1.4

  31. @alandanielfloresmoreno3130 Avatar
    @alandanielfloresmoreno3130

    Zzz

  32. @seylig Avatar
    @seylig

    Heyyy , how did u make ur intro ?? I like it 😉

  33. @caitlinclarke5315 Avatar
    @caitlinclarke5315

    u know u can shoot at 85mm on the 70-200 right? u don't have to shoot far away.

  34. @universaInformation Avatar
    @universaInformation

    200mm for portraits should be medium close up or extreme close up, it's not for full body portrait. That's why you can zoom down to 70mm if you want full body.

  35. @NYourWill Avatar
    @NYourWill

    Can't you just stay below 100mm so you can communicate with the model?

  36. @inspir3d81 Avatar
    @inspir3d81

    At 200mm you don’t feel very engaged? Then just step closer and zoom out!! That’s the whole point of the 70-200mm zoom it allows you both full body and tight headshots with a twist of the wrist!

  37. @AKAJACE1337 Avatar
    @AKAJACE1337

    man this intro is shit, but great content